Michele Vogt finished her athletic career as one of the most decorated athletes in Wilson College history competing in both field hockey and softball. 

As a field hockey player, Vogt was a four-time AWCC All-Conference honoree. In softball, Vogt was a two-time AWCC All-Conference selection.

Vogt also appears in the NCAA record books for numerous statistical categories. Vogt is second all-time in Division III history for batting average in a season with .635 and third all-time in career batting average with .568. In 1999 Vogt led the NCAA in batting average, hitting .588 for the season.