In the 2010 season, Mia Doyle went 9-1 in the regular season at No. 1 singles. In the finals of the NEAC Conference Singles Tennis Championship, Mia defeated the two-time defending champion from Keuka College, earning her
the honor of NEAC Most Outstanding player.

In the 2011 season, Mia again went 9-1 and earned a second-place finish at NEAC Individual Championships. Mia also went undefeated in doubles play in 2011 alongside her sister. Together, the pair captured the NEAC Doubles Championship and had a career record of 20-1 in doubles play.

Doyle is a two-time NEAC All-Conference honoree, earning selections in 2010 and 2011.