Kaitlin entered her first year at Wilson College during the 2022 season. 

Before her time at Wilson, Scheller attended Hood College majoring in Business Administration with a concentration in Marketing. During her time at Hood, she was a member of the softball team; where she was the team captain, an NFCA Scholar-Athlete, President of the Student-Athlete Advisory Committee (SAAC), and All-MAC Commonwealth Honorable mention. During her high school career, she was a 2015 district III qualifier while earning team MVP honors twice, along with being, a three-time First-Team All-Gettysburg Times athlete and a three-time All-Adams County Athlete. 

Scheller brings a wealth of coaching knowledge as she has helped coach local travel teams and high school teams for many years. Kaitlin is asl a Senior Finance Analyst for Bank of America.